Marcus Reynolds is a clinician and lecturer for the British Association of Performing Arts, and the British Trombone Society. Also the creator of Stratos embouchure system, in this feature article (originally published in ‘Brass Band World’) he unravels more mysteries of the embouchure.
“In my last article [click here to read ‘Power over Pressure’], I explained how whistling against your palm would indicate the trajectory of the air. If the top-lip ventures over the bottom lip, then the air is directed against a metal wall – the side of the mouthpiece. When this occurs, great resistance will be felt. By trying to force the same amount of air through the instrument, the cheeks and all sorts of air cushions could start to inflate, vastly reducing the power of the original articulation.
In my previous article, I mentioned whistling or blowing out candles. This will open the teeth and allow more air to travel to the lips. Here’s a trick that keeps the corners of the lips towards the point of pitch, and keeps the cheeks in and the teeth open. Two tongued whistles and then two ‘blow the candles out’, followed by two tongued buzzes.
Practise these three exercises 20 or 30 times. It sounds laborious, but it really is a short cut to clear and powerful precise notes. I cannot see how you perform these exercises, but if you are not relaxed and there is over tension in the neck, the air will not flow. The sensation is that of blowing candles out.
Now we need to ensure that there is enough air being directed towards the aperture so the lips can vibrate most efficiently. Whistle again, or get as close as you can to the shape, keeping your facial muscles still and breathing through the nose. See if you can fit your little finger into the gap between the teeth. Most times you will not be able to because, as you strive for a greater range, the jaw can go into clenching mode, closing the aperture and stifling the air flow.
Let’s next examine the journey of the air from the back of the throat. It must travel without being choked or diverted. Take a breath and use the lips as a ‘stopper’ to inflate the cheeks. Then force your cheeks in to push out the air, but purse your lips so that the air escapes under pressure. You must practice this many times until you start to hear high-pitch squeaks escaping through the lips. These squeaks are actually unrefined notes from above the stave, whatever instrument you play. This process is used in learning to circular breathe.
This is where the Stratos will help; adjust the chin rest to its extreme setting. Keeping the airstream level as you empty your cheeks, aim those squeaks into the mouthpiece – eventually you will be rewarded with the high note clarity you were seeking. So many players start playing into the higher register without foundation.
Try this: play an octave interval well within your comfort range. Start to move upwards in semi- tones. Take your time, going up say five semi-tones, ensure no strain is felt, then go down to where you started. Place the tip of your finger between your teeth to check the gap, and then buzz through the same exercise. The buzzing won’t sound wonderful, but with perseverance the notes will sound freer and richer when you return to playing them because blood and oxygen have been delivered to the lips, and with the buzzing the capillaries and filtrum (the bit between the bottom of the nose and the top lip) are no longer being crushed.
The beauty of Stratos is that it rids students of the fear of changing their playing technique and allows you, or your mentor, to make micro-adjustments that do not hinder your playing.
Many teachers tell their students to use less pressure, but what is being offered as a substitute? Remove the scaffold too early and the building collapses in much the same way that your mouth muscles will, if the mouthpiece weight is removed too quickly. Stratos incrementally reduces the weight of the mouthpiece from the lips until the new muscle memory is self-supporting. “
SIGN UP HERE FOR NEW BLOG ARTICLES EMAILED DIRECT TO YOUR INBOX:
Bob Reeves Brass have been at the forefront of brass custom work for many years now. Regular readers may have already read this great interview with Bob Reeves himself.
The ‘gap’ between mouthpiece and the start of the lead pipe has long been a mystery that is brilliantly explained in this video by Brett.
Watch as he cuts a trumpet mouthpiece for the Reeves Sleeve system, which allows the player to adjust the gap between the end of the mouthpiece and the start of the venturi of the leadpipe. This is a critical adjustment that players can use to fine-tune their trumpet and mouthpiece setup to optimize intonation, response, slotting, and projection.
Marcus Reynolds is an embouchure specialist and founder of the Stratos Embouchure System. I tells us here about his philosophy of ‘Power over Pressure’.
” I was introduced to brass playing at school and later joined a military band, winning a scholarship to the Royal Military School of Music, Kneller Hall, where I studied under Professor Teskey.
Six weeks after leaving the Army, I turned ‘pro’ and did TV and radio, early BBC Come Dancing sessions, West End shows, big band concerts, jingles and other work. I taught for Surrey schools for 12 years and then disaster struck when I fell from a collapsed stage. This caused a smashed lip and Focal Dystonia, and marked the end of my playing career. I had to spend years retraining the muscles in my mouth before I could play again professionally.
I didn’t set out to become an embouchure expert, but my knowledge of the subject was enhanced greatly as a result of the accident. I now teach students all over the world via Skype, even helping top professionals to stay on top of their game. For example, I recently visited Los Angeles, Ohio and Frankfurt to give individual and group embouchure assessments, plus elementary and advanced training on the Stratos Embouchure System (below), which I developed as a result of my quest to play again. I was looking for something to ‘hover’ over my scar tissue, which of course brass players know is not possible.
Moving on from how I got into embouchure training; what follows is a ‘cheat sheet’ to help you become a world-class brass player. The key is to use the natural physiology of the body at all times. Stay upright, bringing the instrument to you – don’t go to it. Do not move the instrument towards you as you are going forward because the note will start with what I call fusion and this mobility will confuse you to the point where you will not know where the note starts.
Try not to slump over your instrument. There is nothing worse than for a conductor to see a sea of players slumping – keep your shoulders down – stay relaxed and breathe evenly. Before I start on the tips for the embouchure, I must stress that any embouchure that works is fine. It’s only when you want to move your playing up (from third stand to second, from second to first, or even as a first foray as a soloist) that you might feel resistance to what you are trying to achieve. It’s time to examine the finer points of the embouchure.
Almost from day one, some lucky players can just play wonderfully, but even after years of experience, such players are unable to advise others about embouchure problems because they simply do not understand the issues involved. Not all of us have been so fortunate! One of the questions is… where is the air going? Hold your palm about six inches in front of your lips and whistle. If you don’t think you can whistle, simply mimic the shape as if you were blowing out a candle. In many cases, the air will be felt between the last joint of the fingers and the upper palm, as illustrated by the diagram below. Now, keeping the hand there, blow as if you are playing your instrument or you could even buzz. You may think that you cannot now feel the air, but further examination will show you that the air can now be felt at the wrist.
One of two things could have happened; your chin dropped back, your top lip ventured over the bottom lip, or possibly a little of both. A brief look at the mouthpiece shows that the back-bore hole is in the middle. Moving the air away from that forward direction will incur even greater resistance because the air is now being blown against a wall of metal. How should you remedy this? This is where Stratos comes into play, providing a healthy way to alleviate the amount of pressure being exerted to increase the airflow as you play higher notes. Possibly for the first time in your playing career, you have something for the chin to ease towards and, in doing so, some of the unnecessary weight is removed from the top lip. Through this process, the ‘chin jut’ reaches towards the chin rest of the Stratos, pulling the corners of the mouth forward. By staying in the ‘jut position’, the chin also adds sonority. “
SIGN UP HERE FOR NEW BLOG ARTICLES EMAILED DIRECT TO YOUR INBOX:
In an effort to share the many ways the ITG serves the worldwide trumpet community, the International Trumpet Guild is regularly sharing content from the ITGJournal on their social media platforms (as well as here on MouthpieceOnline.com!). In January of 2020, they featured one of their ITG Honorary Award winners, Marie Speziale, in an article by Wendy Matthews and Marcelyn Atwood.
Marie was the first woman trumpeter ever to be appointed to a major American orchestra, held the associate principal trumpet position with the Cincinnati Symphony for 32 years, and, more recently, built one of the top trumpet studios in the US at Rice University. Marie is a kind person, nurturing teacher, and wonderful ambassador of the trumpet. Please enjoy learning more about her here:
Education is a lifelong journey, and a journey that often starts in schools around the world that suffer from a lack of funding in music. It is more important than ever to find good quality and reliable resources to help children on their musical journey, as well as adults and advanced learners too. Trumpet Headquarters is a wonderful resource set up by Estela Aragon who was kind enough to talk to me here.
Can you give a little background to your relationship with the trumpet and your professional background?
Do I have a story for you! I began playing trumpet in 6th grade entirely by accident. Back then we had “the wheel” which was a system in which first semester 6th grade students would try an elective for two weeks at a time and then decide which one they wanted to continue for their second semester and on. I tried band for a couple of weeks and during that time we all got trumpets, because it was just to try music, but I thought that meant I had been assigned the trumpet.
See, I didn’t speak English yet as I had recently moved to the United States from my home country Peru, and I was under the impression that I had to play the trumpet! Now, the tryout went great and I was the only student who was able to make a sound on the first try. So, I took that and rolled with it. It was the first time I felt comfortable anywhere, like I belonged, especially in a country where I felt lost due to a language barrier.
That small moment eventually grew into an obsession and passion, which of course became a life-long learning experience. Fast-forward 10ish years and like most musicians in school, I performed as many gigs as possible, and started teaching private lessons in my first year of undergrad. I had a lot of very fulfilling playing experiences from orchestras to weddings to even country music gigs, locally and abroad. It wasn’t until my master’s degree that I decided to focus on private and non-institutional trumpet education. That led me to found my private studio MusicFit Academy, through which I continue to teach full-time today and of course, TrumpetHeadquarters.com, or THQ, was founded shortly after.
What prompted you to setup Trumpet Headquarters?
About 5 years ago I was a in a place of innovation having just wrapped up my master’s degree. I found myself teaching a lot, figuring out life outside of school, and as I grew my private studio I began to run out of times to teach. More and more often I was turning down perfectly good candidates due to time constraints. That’s when I had the “aha” moment to setup some sort of online trumpet lessons course where my prospective students could learn the ropes while they waited for a slot to open.
I also wanted to provide professional and reliable information to counter the massive amount of erroneous guidance floating on the internet. Thus, as the idea was refined, it eventually morphed into not only the trumpet course, but also into an open educational resource for trumpet rated topics. THQ provides a great amount of information for anyone willing to learn.
It’s worth noting that all the resources outside of the trumpet course are free of charge. Want to know about trumpet cases? Mouthpieces? Books for musicians? Best apps for practicing? Notable trumpet players? I have provided all of that information and more. My goal was and will continue to be to educate.
Who is it aimed at?
Simply put; anyone with a trumpet and a hunger to learn how to play it! I approach the course like I approach my private lessons…no fuss, no complications, just simple and easy to understand explanations. I made sure to present the content in a very step-by-step manner.
Absolute beginners will see helpful lessons in posture, breathing, trumpet anatomy and other basics. There is also an introduction to reading sheet music and all the basic techniques and tips for novices, such as how to clearly articulate, slur and change notes evenly. The course goes on to cover intermediate topics such as dexterity, multiple tonguing, range, pitch bending…etc, and of course the advanced lessons delve into even deeper concepts like musicality, lip trills and more.
I have students ranging from ages 9 to 70+, so I think it’s safe to say that the course is well-suited for all ages and skill levels.
What are the key elements that readers should know about it, that sets it apart from other platforms?
As I mentioned, my approach is very simplistic and that alone is an important factor in why the course works. Twisted and over-complicated teaching result in a frustrating learning experience. I also provide a student- only forum where I answer daily questions from them and tend to their needs. They can post pictures and videos of their progress and I reply promptly with my feedback. They really love being able to get that one-on- one attention since naturally, that is a huge setback in self-paced learning.
I have also written over 100 pages of original sheet music with drills and exercises for the course, and I provide other helpful resources such as a fingering chart with all the alternate fingerings; something I haven’t found anywhere else online. Each video features a bullet point list of what I call “Pro Tips”, video chapters, picture-in-picture capabilities and speed change settings. At the bottom of each lesson page, I also provide 3 suggestions for related topics throughout the rest of the website which could be blog entries, a resource page or even a link to another lesson that covers a similar concept.
The bells and whistles are everywhere to ensure a smooth experience for the students as well as an environment to focus on learning. No distractions!
Are there any elements of music education generally that you feel are genuinely lacking at the moment? What can we do to help with this?
Right now, trumpet students all over the world are doing their band classes on Zoom, which of course causes a myriad of drawbacks on its own, but it also highlights the problems in music education that were already there before Covid.
In my professional experience, it is simply impossible for a single band teacher to shape and look after each student. When it comes to brass, and naturally other instruments, we know how important the early few months are. During that time the player will inevitably form habits for the rest of their lives, and if those are bad habits, now you’ve got a player who is struggling, working much harder than they need to and likely will continue to have that experience until they finish high school. Due to the lack of personal attention, students end up with problems such as: incorrectly placed mouthpieces, air control issues, severe tension problems, a lack of tone concept, efficiency and endurance problems, and many more. But what can we really do about it?
It is simply not realistic to expect band teachers to know the in and outs of every instrument, or to know how to precisely diagnose problems and even if they did, there is not enough time for them to guide 80+ students individually. For this reason I advocate bringing specialized artists into the classroom and now that we are so accustomed to Zoom, there is really no barrier for who you can bring in your student’s radar. Bringing in artists helps more than just the students; it also lightens the load for the band director and contributes to the flow of jobs for musicians.
I do understand that there is a cost involved and not all band programs have the means, so that is a hoop that some have to jump through and find creative solutions for. At THQ I also offer a hefty discount for band programs who want to get all of their trumpet players on the same page by signing up for the course as a section. This could also be a more cost- effective solution for when hiring an artist to teach weekly masterclasses is not possible.
While this is a big gap in music education, and solutions are difficult to afford, we can all work together to come up with affordable options. So if you’re an artist, I encourage you to come up with a group class blueprint, put an attainable price tag on it and pitch it to schools. It’s a great way to make an impact and an income.
What new developments are you currently working on?
I have so many plans for this year I don’t even know where to begin! I just finished adding 18 beginner duets in response to a poll from my students asking for play-along material. I now plan on adding duet content for the intermediate and advanced levels as well. We can learn so much from playing duets of course, so I’m excited to provide this layer of education to the course.
Naturally, more content is coming for all levels. As I come across topics in my private lessons and with colleagues I write them down to bring them into the course as tutorials on many different concepts from playing, to practicing to mental preparation. Prospective students can certainly look forward to a growing a library of trumpet lessons.
I do have something big in the works for this year…and I mean big. I can’t give away too many details, but I will say that it will provide a solution to the greatest setbacks self-taught trumpet players have; accountability and overwhelm of what to practice. This will be part of the course later this year and I’ll be back to talk about it when it’s almost out of the oven!
Thanks for your time Estela. Is there anything else that you would like to add?
I’d like to welcome trumpet players, from beginners to pros, to come visit TrumpetHeadquarters.com. The site provides a lot of useful content for teachers, curated lists of books, apps and so much more I can’t list here. It really is the headquarters of all things trumpet and I love to share it with everyone.
For those interested in learning, just sign-up for the course! If you have any questions feel free to email me directly at trumpetheadquarters@gmail.com, and if you just want to keep in touch or wait for the next big sale make sure you sign up for the free newsletter on the homepage.
Thanks for this fun interview John!
SIGN UP HERE FOR NEW BLOG ARTICLES EMAILED DIRECT TO YOUR INBOX:
What have our favourite players practiced to sound so great?
What secrets have they learnt to improvise so melodically and effortlessly?
Well, I can tell you from personal experience of working and studying with many great players is that they have developed their jazz vocabulary!
A great way to do this is by listening to the greats of the music.
As Clark Terry used to say – Imitate, Assimilate, Innovate.
Many of the wonderful players that we listen to have taken jazz vocabulary and made it there own, sometimes by adding other great players’ in fluences or by practicing language and vocabulary so much that they start to hear their own things to play. The more you develop the skills of practicing vocabulary, especially in all 12 keys, the more you develop your own aural skills and imagination. Developing the skill of instantly being able to play what you hear in your head is what every musician wants but how is this achieved?
To hear wonderful jazz phrases in our heads, we must practice the language or vocabulary of the masters of the music, if we don’t, we can still improvise but it has a real chance of not sounding authentic!
If you are new to improvising and developing your aural skills, here is an exercise you can start doing straight away to develop
1. What you hear 2. The ability to play it.
I would recommend staring off with extremely simple tunes, like a nursery rhyme! I have created a short YouTube video on this subject using ‘Twinkle twinkle little star’ as the tune to practice.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wl1goUXBmOM
Try and play it, starting on various different notes (all 12 keys would be best). At first it may prove quite a challenge, especially in the more unfamiliar keys!
By doing this, you develop the ability to play what you hear in your head!
The next thing to do it to try and learn (really well) either a simple jazz tune (when the Saints is pretty simple) or if you feel you are ready, learn 8 bars of your favourite solo by your favourite player! This is the imitate part! Play it over and over until it is very easy! Next, either chromatically or in a cycle of 5ths or 4ths (depends if you are going up or down), learn it fluently in all the other keys! This really well prove to be frustrating at first, but the more you do it, the easier it becomes, especially if studying one player.
Once you have learnt an 8 bar phrase, keep going until you can play the whole solo. You don’t have to play the whole solo in all 12 keys, just the parts you really like. This is the assimilate part! By building up an armoury of phrases & vocabulary, you will always have something to play, the more you have, the better your solos will be. Especially by working out why some phrases sound so good.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nBH2ryHgPYM
Once you have practiced and can fluently play lots of your favourite phrases, analyse them, work out why it sounds so good. This is the innovate part. What is it about the phrase you like? Could it be rhythmic, melodic…? What ever it is, try to create your own phrases using the techniques that they have! This will help us to not simply copy and paste other musicians licks, endlessly into out own solos! There are many that do it, try not to be one of them!
For me, the best jazz musicians are those who play beautiful, endless melodic phrases without (it seems) ever playing licks! Why do they sound so good? Well they are still using the vocabulary that makes jazz sound so great, they are just so imaginative and have endless creativity! They also have wonderful ears and play/outline the changes very well. If you listened to a solo of Clifford Brown with any rhythm section, you would still hear the chords being outlined in his solos! The same with Chet Baker, Bobby Shew, Blue Mitchell, Chuck Findley, Warren Vache……
If your current ability is not up to playing the music of these amazing players, I have created jazz etudes, with the beginner/intermediate player in mind. Jazz etudes, written over famous chord sequences (jazz standards) and in different genres including, dixieland, bebop, standards and latin (bossanova).
When we are learning the phrases, we are learning to speak the language of jazz, the correct grammar if you will. We want to make sense when we solo.
This is a music that takes a lifetime to master. We should be constantly challenging ourselves with different ways to approach our practice of improvisation and solos.
I don’t know when it happens but there does come a time when you do start to hear authentic things in your head. The more you practice and the more you listen to the and study the greats of the music, the more chance you have to create beautiful sounding solos yourself.
Just remember that Rome wasn’t built in a day and you have your whole life to work at this wonderful music! Be patient with yourself, seek out great players and teachers to learn from, transcribe solos and work your favourite phrases into your own playing, try to play together with other musicians too (ones that are much better but supportive if possible). You should also learn to spell out the chords and scales on your instruments too, this will prove invaluable in helping you to get around the chord changes.
I hope you find this article informative and helpful.
Warm regards, Darren Lloyd
SIGN UP HERE FOR NEW BLOG ARTICLES EMAILED DIRECT TO YOUR INBOX:
“Mental practice preparation” – Getting ourselves in the right frame of mind, and then planning and executing our practice goals – an article by Sam Neufeld of ‘Trumpet Warmup’.
2020 was difficult at times to stay motivated to practice. Gigs dried up and so did motivation to keep our chops together. Luckily there are some things we can do to get back on track.
Here are three strategies I am using in 2021 that you can use too:
Set the bar low
Remove distraction
Track progress
Overall the name of the game is to develop consistency.
Let’s break it down…
Setting the bar low for practice time.
A couple weeks ago, my friend mentioned he was going to start working out everyday. Last year he worked out only a handful of times and wanted to change that. I asked him, “how certain are you that you can workout seven days a week? Are you 100% certain that you won’t miss a single day?”
Well, of course the answer was no. He could not say with complete confidence that he’d not miss a single day especially since his previous track record was so different.
I said to him “Instead of attempting to workout everyday, start with something you know you’ll complete with 100% certainty.”
Set the bar SO LOW that you cannot fail. This is a strategy that’s worked wonders for me in the past and I am using it this year to start practicing consistently again and improve my trumpet playing. I missed somewhere between 30-60 days last year and because of it my playing suffered. In order to get back on track, I’ve set the bar low by pledging to practice everyday for at least 5 minutes. There will be days that I practice 2+ hours, but 5 minutes minimum per day gets me back on track towards forming the daily habit of practicing.
Remove distraction from the practice space.
Where do you practice currently? During Covid-19 times, it’s likely a bedroom or office space. If you’re lucky – an isolated practice space or garage. But, you don’t need a separate/isolated room. What may help you most is a dedicated practice space. Somewhere you have everything needed to complete a successful practice session.
In this space you need:
Mirror
Tuner
Trumpet stand
Music stand
Chair
Water bottle
Optional:
Computer or tv
Camera
Microphone
Mutes
Coffee
Other trumpet gadgets
I treat this like going to the gym. What do you bring with you before leaving for the gym? Water bottle, change of clothes, shampoo, etc… Treat practicing the same way this year. Don’t let the fact that you’re stuck in your apartment next to your tv distract you. Remove the distractions physically if possible, but more importantly – mentally.
Record video and audio to track progress.
Accountability is a great motivator for staying true to your goal. If you have a private teacher, this is one form of accountability. Your teacher adds pressure to practice each week that wouldn’t otherwise be there.
Here’s another form of accountability that you may not already be utilizing: Instagram.
Create an account dedicated to practicing. Post your videos even if they suck. Get over the fear of “what will so-and-so think”. This is about improving over time, not sounding good every single day. You don’t have to like other people’s posts or comment fire emojis if you don’t want to. Although I suspect over time you will end up finding a friendly community of like-minded trumpet players that you enjoy engaging with.
By posting to Instagram, you will have accountability and a practice log. Months or years later you can analyze your past videos to see if you’ve actually improved or not!
So this is my strategy for 2021. It’s time to get back on track.
Brass players, including those at the top of their professional tree, have experienced Focal Dystonia that has either permanently, or temporarily, halted playing. Marcus Reynolds was a ‘pro’ player who overcame the challenge and here offers his personal (as opposed to medical) perspective on the road to recovery.
“I was inspired to write this for several reasons, not the least of which was an accident when I fell from a stage, which badly damaged my lip. My resultant anxiety about how I was going to play again and continue to make a living led to my own experience of Focal Dystonia (FD). I have learned to play again and it has been a struggle, but I have learned much about FD and embouchure problems along the way, which I’d like to share that with other brass players and teachers.
Dystonia is uncontrollable muscle spasms caused by faulty signals from the brain. Focal refers to a condition affecting a precise area of the body, such as the lips and muscles supporting the embouchure. Experiencing FD is a bit like dealing with a sat-nav that can’t understand that your route is blocked. Progress cannot be made, frustration mounts, only aggravating the situation. The sat-nav may even need to be turned off and the driver resort to basics (eyes and a map!). Similarly, the FD sufferer returns to basics, or in medical terms the brain’s cortical map needs untangling.
When a brass player visits me with FD, the first thing I aim to do is to change the name of the condition. For some, the mere mention of FD can amplify the associated problems, even triggering involuntary muscle movements, so I try to use a different terminology when discussing their playing. Typically, an FD sufferer is unable to control the lips as needed, so often I start sessions with certain facial exercises, which look like gurning, followed by some gentle buzzing using the Stratos embouchure training aid that I have developed. I set Stratos so the lips are hardly touching the mouthpiece. In that position, the brain does not register an instrument is being played. This avoids full contact on the lips, which would allow the brain to associate the problem with the instrument, thus triggering a rejection of it. Playing with some of the usual weight on the lips removed is difficult at first, but it cheats the brain to the extent that the student does not produce and hear the heavily debilitating ‘bu bu bu’ sound generally associated with the symptoms of FD. After a few repetitions of this exercise, clearer notes appear, almost like magic.
This rehabilitation is about re-routing the cortical map and, to achieve this, I have created a series of mind and muscle distracting exercises. A main aim is to build a new embouchure and the unpolished sounds that the instrument might emit are part of the process of recovery. A beginner’s early, unfocused sounds are similar to those made by an FD sufferer, but I believe that FD sufferers should be treated almost like beginners who often take time to achieve a really nice sound, but do not shun or reject the instrument because they have no ‘history’ to compare a better sound to. Experienced players, however, appreciate a good sound, so are frustrated when they cannot produce it.
Even when a smooth, even-toned note is being produced, FD can suddenly trigger an involuntary spasm resulting in a high-pitched squeak. However, as there will often have been a good quality note before the problem arises, I try to get the player to produce notes in semi-tones, either side of the targeted good note.
Repeating this extensively can achieve a new stability, controlled by a new muscle memory, triggering new synapse messages to the brain. Recovery is partly about breaking what we might call ‘historic spasms’ – that is spasms arising from old ways of playing. For valve instruments, this can be tackled by using different fingering, so in the case of a valve instrument, I get my student to play a scale of C. Then, as we ascend from low C (after pre-pitching an E top space, also thinking downwards and cerebrally pitching, as if you were whistling), I get the G played in 1st and 3rd, the A in 3rd, the B in 1st and 3rd, and the remaining C in 2nd and 3rd. This way, the instrument is raising the pitch and not the lips. Before starting this C scale, I strive for an E top space to be blown with no tongue, and then encourage the player to think the interval to the C in the stave and to play the scale by not changing pitch facially, but by allowing the instrument to take the pitch downwards. This exercise is carried out very calmly. If the ‘bu bu bu’ occurs, show no sign of annoyance or frustration because your student will reflect it – just start again.
The next technique sounds a little crazy, especially as the player may not be very confident using the methods to play any of the notes that I’ve mentioned. Using the Stratos, with its unique adjustment set with the chin-rest piston as far forward as it will go, I encourage the player to reach towards the mouthpiece, sat the same time depressing the chin rest piston spring and closing the gap to the mouthpiece. Although sometimes frustrating, this exercise increases the blood and oxygen to the capillaries, strengthening the mouth muscles. Reaching towards the mouthpiece will feel alien, but will cause no evidence of FD because ‘historic spasms’ won’t be triggered. Maintain this exercise for a full minute, then rest. Return the chin-rest so it is just touching the chin and then play. Results will vary, but I find that the player has better support and, in many cases, plays without the ‘bu bu bu’ effect.
Whistling arpeggios is great, even if a whistle cannot be achieved; just copy the shape as you whistle. Not only does this firm up the oral chamber, but it also encourages the ‘smiling’ muscles to draw forwards towards the point of pitch. Do this exercise very slowly and deliberately, using your mind to picture the travel of the tongue as it arches upwards for the higher whistled notes and then feel the tongue flatten as you descend the arpeggio.
Another strategy is for the player to go into unfamiliar areas, such as striving to pitch above their normal range. The brain won’t know what is happening and so FD won’t be triggered. Once some success has been achieved, work downwards in pitch suspension, not losing sight of the higher note. After descending two or three notes, return to the first note. If these notes feel and sound clear, descend four notes.
Three of my students with FD had never buzzed before, but buzzing keeps the capillaries open, allowing more blood and oxygen into the lips. The brutality of the mouthpiece pressing against flesh needs to be reduced and using the Stratos will achieve this, a little at a time.
Once you’ve made a good start on producing a reasonable sound, you can proceed to rebuilding the embouchure properly. Avoiding old habits is central, but often comes down to basics for a beginner. So progress comes from patient concentration on producing a smooth airflow, correct posture of neck and body, comfortable handling of the instrument and, of course, effective breathing. I recommend looking at the teaching of Kristian Steenstrupp, Professor of Trumpet at the Royal Academy of Music in Aarhus, on this matter.
If the player does not feel that the results are favourable at anytime, I return to the good notes and start again, which helps to anchor that one good note as a rung on the ladder to eventual success.
Many of the players that I’ve helped are overwhelmed by anxiety to such a degree that they find it immensely difficult to accept there is a way out of their dilemma. It is easy to think ‘why me?’ That attitude, however, only sustains the collapse of the player’s skills and rejection of the instrument that is symptomatic of FD. It is important to recognise that mental attitude to playing is important. I, too, was a ’pro’ making a living as a ‘bone’ player, teaching, conducting and performing for TV and radio. The stress of worrying about how to make a living was the factor that compounded other neuroses that I experienced. The way forward is to try to create different sensations that trick the brain and muscles into re- learning that what they are doing.
I try to create different sensations so that the brain asks what is happening, and, in those moments of confusion by using subterfuge and deception, new and different approaches can be made without rejection. Many alternative avenues are needed for continued progress. For example everything you do to change the feel mentally and sensorily will help this confusion. Even something like wearing gloves, so the instrument feels totally different, can provide a new sensory experience, distracting the brain and aiding progress.
In summary, recovery is possible if the player is patient and works diligently with the tutor.”
This article was originally published in ‘Brass Band World’
Transcription is a great skill to develop in itself, but is also invaluable for developing our ears and our general musical awareness. Darren Lloyd from ‘Jazz etudes’ talks here about how to actually go about this and develop this important musical skill:
https://youtu.be/nBH2ryHgPYM
Sign up here for new Mouthpiece Online blog articles emailed direct to your inbox:
Marcus Reynolds is a signed Rath trombone artist, soloist, recording artist, clinician, embouchure specialist, tutor, lecturer for the British Association of Performing Arts Medicine and creator of the Stratos Embouchure System. Here Marcus shares his views on the brass player’s embouchure, what can go wrong and how to avoid the common pitfalls and problems.
Hello and welcome to this discussion of the brass embouchure. The basis of this article is a lecture that I gave during one of my Brass Detox clinics at the Welsh College of Music and Drama at the request of the British Trombone Society. Such was the strong interest and positive feedback that I was asked to contribute it to The Brass Herald and now to Mouthpiece Online.
“You missed by a mile,” shouted the disgruntled football fan as the ball failed to hit its target, resulting in his team being relegated. “Oh, you missed!” said his girlfriend when he shot wide on a fairground shooting range, losing them the chance to strut around with the ubiquitous giant cuddly teddy. No, you have not picked up the wrong magazine. Read on, all will become clear.
Simply explained, even if you are only slightly inaccurate at the point of launch the trajection angle will still be such that you will appear to have missed by a mile. When a note you are trying to play is missed, you have in reality only missed it by a fraction. However, human nature being what it is, all sorts of events ensue, for example, the “shock horror” of playing a wrong note encourages the player to beat themselves up, causing val-salva, clenching of the throat muscles, shoulders rising and without question increased weight being applied to the lips. Any one of these factors makes the road ahead more difficult. As many of you will know, if you have not shrugged off the aftermath of playing a note that was not in the right place the next few notes are affected. This can be addressed in your practice.
Tip: When you next practice a piece and you play a note that you wish you hadn’t, don’t stop immediately – play on for a few bars and absorb the fact that the world ain’t gonna come to a standstill, and if you learn not to show a body twitch or facial grimace then most of the time you will be the only one who knows.
Tip: Everyone says: “Practice makes perfect.” I tell my students: “Practice makes permanent.” So play a new piece slowly.
The physiological process to fortify the lips goes like this:
Conversation/communication brain to lips: “What’s going on?”
“He/she is blowing into that metal thing again – how long is that going on for?”
“Dunno boss, last time it was for two hours. Right, we will send more blood to help the muscles cope.”
Half an hour later: “What now?” says the brain to the lip department. “More blood needed for the muscles.” “We sent loads.” “Yeah, but it’s not getting through.”
Now I know I have made this a little cartoon like, but the facts are these:
Blood and oxygen are sent to reinforce an area that is being constantly exercised and placed under stress until that area, be it with a tennis player, golfer or any athlete, becomes accustomed to that particular activity. That happens where and when the reinforcement (blood and oxygen) have done the job of replenishing the muscle sufficiently.
The dilemma is this: if the area – and in our case a player’s lips – are constantly bombarded with pressure and weight, the blood flow will be held up.
Then the brain receives the message “Can’t get through”. The sad news is that the very antidote to our lips failing to work properly has been ordered by the natural physiology of the body. It is not able to provide the service it has been sent to perform as the lips are being constantly impacted, crushing the capillaries. It is a sort of self-induced tourniquet.
Many teachers tell their students to use less pressure and, yes, many reading this will have heard similar statements. But what is offered as a substitute? If a building is being supported by scaffolding that is then removed before the structure can support itself, the building will fall down.
The beauty of Stratos is that you can control how much of the scaffold you remove until the “internal muscular scaffold” can hold its own. Many players who now use a Stratos have found that there is an alternative to the “Pressure Trap” and are already enjoying playing more. They discover that the pain that is sometimes present while playing is vastly reduced and in most cases disappears completely after a while. While this process is taking place you will not be alone wherever you are in the world. I am only an e-mail away.
While we’re thinking about the collapse of the embouchure, let’s go back to the word trajection. Players sometimes very clearly “crane” their head and neck to enable them a better view of the music, often causing them to be blighted by that same position throughout their playing life. The stylised holding of an instrumentat a slight angle, changing mouthpiece position and adding range by slightly twisting one way or another, is also found. Any gains are very short lived. If you are not careful such unhelpful habits become built into your embouchure.
Tip: Try to keep everything in line. It is easy to monitor – just play in front of a mirror, try to keep your body in line, stand or sit upright then bring the instrument to you. We are all guilty with regard to bad posture at times. Putting it right is a basic requirement no matter what you go on to do with the instrument on your lips.
What never ceases to amaze me is when I see band members sitting with instruments about to play a concert and there’s no warming-up going on. Go to a West End show, the opera house or any symphony orchestra and you will hear musicians warming or limbering up for their performance. But the warm-up should start well before the performance. When I have a concert I prepare very early, maybe even up at 7.00am. Then for the first ten minutes I hardly brush the mouthpiece with the lightest buzzing. This is BEFORE breakfast, so that when I return to the instrument the very fine coating on the lips has muscularly dissolved a sort of restrictive “cling-film” that has been left over from the night before. This cling film in effect is lactic acid repairing and comforting your lips that have been compacted by the mouthpiece for so many hours, a coating that is saying “leave me alone I need to rest”.
That brings me to another point. I am aware that at the end of a performance everybody wants to get packed up and out. Instead, try playing a few low notes with flarpy lips, just for ten or twenty seconds. Then while you are packing up, roll the chops to let the blood and oxygen into the capillaries. Then the next day’s lactic acid “cling-film” should not be clinging on so tenaciously and shouldfall away more quickly, so you can get on with what you so love doing – playing.
As a musician, with whatever genre you are being asked to perform, you need to look after yourself and particularly that precious vermillion circle that is the lips. So I am hoping that you will have read something here that might ring true and will help you in the future.
That leads me to the Filtrum, or infranasal depression. What? – I hear you say.
It’s that bit of the mouth between the bottom of the nose and the top lip. I don’t want to get too technical, but it does have a bearing on why the embouchure can collapse. One of the main reasons is because behind the filtrum there are many nerve endings and when playing has been sustained with constant crushing weight on the lips, this causes them to get a little numb as the blood and oxygen has been squeezed away. They just don’t respond.
In performance, to stop playing is not always an option, so just ensure when you have a few bars’ rest, roll your lips to open the capillaries and allow blood and oxygen to enter these tiny blood vessels and renew tired muscles.
After constant bombardment with no break for the lips, the numbness can become so severe that all the feeling disappears and the lip loses all sense of harmonic positioning, playing becomes impossible and the embouchure feels as if it has collapsed. That is where Stratos begins to help, as using Stratos for at least ten to fifteen minutes of your practice time will put sufficient “petrol in the tank” (muscle power) for you not to get this numbness.
However, like all petrol tanks the fuel will run out and you will need to top up with a further session using Stratos. Even if you continue to experience numbness, the symptoms should not be as severe and you will recover more quickly and prevent a total collapse of the embouchure.
Space prevents me sharing many more golden nuggets from my forty years in teaching and performing, but if I was Dr Chops here is my prescription that will help smooth out the bumps of your brass-playing life. I am passionate about helping players to avoid some of the maladies and pitfalls that can cripple even some very proficient performers. With social media and technology via Skype or FaceTime I am constantly presented with students around the globe having problems that could have been spotted earlier (remember the bit about trajection) that have held up their progress and created bigger problems. Don’t just take my word for everything you have read, get into and read The Art of Brass Playing by Philip Farkas, How Brass Players Do It by John Ridgeon and The Encyclopaedia of the Pivot System by Donald Reinhardt. Finally, I will leave you with something to try.
On the subject that whatever you play is the amplifier and the real instrument is your lips – you tune your instrument so let’s now tune the lips.
Tip: When you are working on a new musical passage or phrase that is getting tough – stop playing for a few seconds, then buzz the phrase two or three times even if you don’t achieve a very musical outcome. The lips will thank you for the rest away from the mouthpiece and reward you with more sonority and a much freer sound. After a while you may be rewarded with what my students achieve – what I call “Cerebral Pitching” resulting in the notes starting to float.
Some points to be aware of to avoid a total collapse of the embouchure:
The Vicious Circle:
Stiffness in the lips and muscles surrounding them.
Swellings on the vermillion circle that take longer to recover.
Headaches caused by air not being able to escape through clenched teeth.
Mis-pitching in the lower register.
Less sonority in your sound.
Taking longer to recover from the previous playing session.
Declining stamina.
Less flexibility.
Having to use more and more effort to maintain the standard you usually expect from yourself.
Here’s to safer, healthier and more joyful playing!
This article was originally published in The Brass Herald in 2015.
Sign up here for new blog articles emailed direct to your inbox:
Cookie Consent
We use cookies to improve your experience on our site. By using our site, you consent to cookies.
Contains information related to marketing campaigns of the user. These are shared with Google AdWords / Google Ads when the Google Ads and Google Analytics accounts are linked together.
90 days
__utma
ID used to identify users and sessions
2 years after last activity
__utmt
Used to monitor number of Google Analytics server requests
10 minutes
__utmb
Used to distinguish new sessions and visits. This cookie is set when the GA.js javascript library is loaded and there is no existing __utmb cookie. The cookie is updated every time data is sent to the Google Analytics server.
30 minutes after last activity
__utmc
Used only with old Urchin versions of Google Analytics and not with GA.js. Was used to distinguish between new sessions and visits at the end of a session.
End of session (browser)
__utmz
Contains information about the traffic source or campaign that directed user to the website. The cookie is set when the GA.js javascript is loaded and updated when data is sent to the Google Anaytics server
6 months after last activity
__utmv
Contains custom information set by the web developer via the _setCustomVar method in Google Analytics. This cookie is updated every time new data is sent to the Google Analytics server.
2 years after last activity
__utmx
Used to determine whether a user is included in an A / B or Multivariate test.
18 months
_ga
ID used to identify users
2 years
_gali
Used by Google Analytics to determine which links on a page are being clicked
30 seconds
_ga_
ID used to identify users
2 years
_gid
ID used to identify users for 24 hours after last activity
24 hours
_gat
Used to monitor number of Google Analytics server requests when using Google Tag Manager