What difference does mouthpiece material make?

This is too a broad question and also very difficult to judge!  I ask it because I came across a now-discontinued Sterling Silver Yamaha 14B4 trumpet mouthpiece a short while ago and was very interested to find out…

1. What difference the silver makes…and

2. Why they were discontinued.

Question 2 is probably pretty straightforward to answer. Where they are still showing as available in the UK, the retail cost of them is around £300, which is most certainly not a price bracket that we are accustomed to with Yamaha.

What difference the silver makes requires some playing and listening, so I have lined up 3 mouthpieces that are all advertised as having the same rim and cup profiles from Yamaha and will test them on a Xeno 8335RGS and a Bach 180ML37:

Standard 14B4 Trumpet Mouthpiece

Custom GP (heavyweight) 14B4 Trumpet Mouthpiece

Custom 925 Sterling Silver 14B4 Trumpet Mouthpiece

I played each mouthpiece on both trumpets at a range of dynamics and registers using a variety of attacks and articulations. I took notes based on how they ‘felt’, and also recorded them closely-miked to get an idea of how they would perform for me in the studio. I also asked a trumpeter friend (although they may not be for much longer after the racket that I subjected them to!) to listen from the other side of the room and take their own notes.

The whole lot makes for a long (and not particularly interesting) read, so I have done a summary below and would very much welcome thoughts from other players (and indeed designers and manufacturers) on these and any other mouthpieces made from non-brass.

The Standard mouthpiece gives a nice even sound across the range, although it gets overly bright for me in the upper register and doesn’t really open out enough for my taste in the lower registers.  This is probably partly to do with the fact that although I generally have always played on 14 style (Bach 3) rims, I have also always opened out the throats to give less resistance.  The brightness and ‘edge’ that I was experiencing was also picked up on by my audient and to a lesser degree by my close-miked recording.

The Custom GP mouthpiece is also brass and has more mass around the outside of the cup.  Immediately I felt a huge tonal difference.  The sound was much more centred and had a richer and more solid tonal core across the registers.  I could not however get a brightness of sound (even on the 8335RGS) at louder dynamics that I would want.  Interestingly, my listener at the other side said that there was not much difference at louder dynamics to the standard model.  This was also the case listening back to the recording, suggesting that the biggest difference with the GP model is in feel and comfort from a playing perspective rather than necessarily in sound.

The Sterling Silver model has a similar volume to the standard (a bach-ish style blank) but is certainly a few grams heavier than the standard due to the material.  It felt instantly different – more tonal core (quite similar to the heavier GP), but surprisingly also a massively quicker response.  Unlike the GP model, what I was feeling as a richer sound did actually come across to the audience and the difference could clearly be heard on the recording.  Generally you would expect this from a tighter or shallower-cupped mouthpiece, but not necessarily from something like the 14B4.  The rim and cup profiles, the throat and backbore should all be the same as the standard model, however this mouthpiece responded completely differently.

I mentioned earlier that I generally open out my mouthpieces to a 25 or 26 throat. This silver model has a standard narrower 27 throat, yet has a strange combination of the open sound that you associate with a larger mouthpiece with the quick response and overtones that you can get from a smaller more resistant piece.

What do my fellow trumpeters think? I would be really interested to hear what you have thought about non-brass mouthpieces.  There are obviously a lot of options now available made out of synthetic materials and plastics. Has anyone experimented with metals other than brass, and is there scope and/or a financial viability for designers and manufacturers to explore this further?

Numerous mouthpiece options are available along with specialist advice from Thompson Music.


Sign up here for new blog articles emailed direct to your inbox:

[jetpack_subscription_form show_subscribers_total=”false” button_on_newline=”false” submit_button_text=”Sign up” custom_font_size=”16″ custom_border_radius=”0″ custom_border_weight=”1″ custom_padding=”15″ custom_spacing=”10″ submit_button_classes=”” email_field_classes=”” show_only_email_and_button=”true”]

Trumpet Artist Profile: Steve Fishwick

With a rapidly growing profile on the UK and International Jazz circuits, and an ever-increasing back catalogue of critically-acclaimed recordings to his name, I am immensely grateful to trumpeter and Schilke Artist, Steve Fishwick for giving up his time to share his thoughts and insights…

Tell us about how you got into trumpet playing, and your main influences.

“Aged 8, I started having lessons with a wonderful teacher called John Crosdale who had spent time in the Halle orchestra.  My twin brother Matt (now a drummer) made fun of me for a week then decided that he wanted to play too.  I think our parents thought we’d give it up in a few months.  Mr Crosdale used to regale my parents with stories of his professional trumpet playing days, so to an 8 or 9 year old, this was the greatest thing ever.  By the age of 10, I had more or less made up my mind that I was going to be a professional musician, not really having any idea what that entailed or how hard it would be!

I’ll be forever grateful to Mr Crosdale because he was so curious and enthusiastic about music.  When my brother and I started getting interested in jazz, he didn’t discourage it, he was very positive and excited by it even though he was a classical trumpet player.  At the time, the 1980s jazz boom was underway. Wynton Marsalis’ fame was at its peak so he was on the TV all the time along with Courtney Pine, Tommy Smith and Andy Sheppard.  Plus, they were showing old jazz 625s on the TV which we used to video tape and watch over and over.  I remember going to see Dizzy Gillespie with the United Nations Orchestra (with Arturo Sandoval and Claudio Roditi) and our teacher Mr Crosdale was in attendance too.  At our next lesson, he presented us with a programme signed by Dizzy, he’d gone backstage after the concert to meet the band and chat to Arturo about trumpet technique!  He really was an inspirational teacher.

I had got into some bad habits, playing on the red of my lip, so I undertook an embouchure change.  I had no idea what I was doing, I just changed position and told myself: “right that’s where I’m putting the mouthpiece from now on” and it kind of worked.  Then we went to London to study at the Royal Academy of Music under Graham Collier (we were there 1994-98).  Steve Waterman was my teacher along with Gerard Precenser (for my final year) who was very inspirational.  I also had some lessons from vibraphonist Anthony Kerr who was very helpful when I was trying to get fast tempos together, and Martin Speake was great too.  I played pretty convincing jazz when I arrived at college but I didn’t really know technically what I was doing (I was playing mainly by ear).  Martin found me out on day one and proceeded to roast me.  I was a little headstrong and stupid in those days and rebelled quite a bit, but the lessons stuck with me and much, much later I eventually caught on to what they were trying to tell me!

I should also mention Lew Soloff who I had the good fortune of working with in Pete Long’s Gillespiana.  I had met him in New York a little while before this too.  He was very encouraging, but told me in no uncertain terms that I needed to improve my technique, particularly my breathing.  He turned me onto the Arnold Jacobs breathing exercises which I’ve been working on ever since, along with the Chicowicz long tones and flow studies (which Terrell Stafford turned me onto).  I would say that these two things, more than anything else, have improved my trumpet technique immensely.

As for players that I admire, there are a lot!  Main influences I would say are Kenny Dorham, Miles Davis, Art Farmer, Lee Morgan, Freddie Hubbard, Blue Mitchell, Donald Byrd, Clifford Brown, Woody Shaw, Charlie Parker and Dizzy.  I often feel torn between the Kenny Dorham/Miles Davis vulnerable introspection and the more gregarious extrovert Lee Morgan and Freddie Hubbard.  So, I guess I’m trying to balance the two things in some way.  I also listen to more contemporary players like Joe Magnarelli, Ritchie Vitale, Wallace Roney, Scott Wendholt and pretty much anyone playing now.  I try and keep up with all the contemporary players: Avishai Cohen, Ambrose Akinmusire, Michael Rodriguez and the rest of them.  Plus, we have some very fine jazz trumpet players over here in the UK who are very inspiring, such as Percy Pursglove, Tom Walsh and Robbie Robson.  I also like to listen to classical music too.”

What model trumpet do you play?

“I am playing a Schilke HC-1.  For a long time, I played a Martin Committee from the 1940s, but I wore the thing out, put my hands through the brass and everything.  Even after I had it reconditioned it just became unviable to play as my everyday horn.  I got another Martin but the tuning wasn’t fantastic.  Then I moved onto Olds Supers which I liked, incredible projection, but I never felt like I could hear myself very well – Probably because the horn was so good at projecting!  I eventually bought a Schilke B1 after a lot of research.  Basically, I like lightweight horns with step bore and a reverse leadpipe.  I like to feel the horn vibrate in my hands as I’m playing it.  The B1 is great, it has a wide variety of tonal expression, and out front it doesn’t sound bright at all.  But from behind the horn it does sound a little bright.  So, I’ve moved onto the HC-1 which, although it was designed for Wallace Roney, I feel it could have been designed personally for me!  It is a fantastic amalgamation of the Martin Committee and the classic Schilke designs, two of my favourite horns.  The sound is great, the tuning perfect and the resistance from low to upper register is amazingly consistent.  For me personally and for what I’m trying to do, they are the best horns out there.”

…and mouthpiece?!

“I play on a Monette B2S3 Prana Resonance Mouthpiece.  I’ve experimented a lot – Used to play big mouthpieces, moved to shallow ones and gradually went bigger again.  I think most jazz players want something that can give them a big, warm sound but also enables them to get into the upper register.  So, everything is a little bit of a compromise between sound and range, deep and shallow.  The Monette mouthpiece isn’t a compromise, great sound and the upper register is easier.  If I try and play a conventional mouthpiece now, it just doesn’t work.  And the sound is nowhere close to the Monettes (for me personally, not that other players can’t make conventional mouthpieces sound great, I mean Clifford Brown didn’t need it!).  I feel that they also ‘correct’ your playing in some way.  If I’m not using my air correctly or I have tension somewhere in my body then the mouthpiece just kind of shuts down, it doesn’t work.  I don’t consider myself the greatest trumpet technician as it’s something I’ve always struggled with, so I need the daily reminder!”

What are the most important aspects of trumpet playing that young, aspiring musicians should focus on?

“I think an aspiring player should concentrate on sound.  There is a lot to think about when learning any instrument, so I think that sound sometimes goes out of the window.  Along with this goes correct breathing and listening a lot to the greats.  A lot of younger players don’t know how to listen, and in a lot of ways it isn’t their fault.  They have Spotify, YouTube and all of this music at their fingertips, so they end up listening to different stuff every day.  There is a lot to be said for the old way of getting a bunch of CDs and listening to them repeatedly, internalising them and really learning every note on the record.  Also, listening isn’t as social as it used to be when you would get together with friends and listen to music.  Everybody listens on headphones on their phone or computer in isolation.  Do yourself a favour and buy a decent stereo system!  It will sound so much better and you will hear details in the music you won’t have heard before.  Also, you’ll experience the joy of listening and sharing music with friends.  I feel listening and internalising the sound of great players is hugely important, it will give you a strong concept of what you want to sound like.  And if you don’t have that strongly in your mind, it will never come out of the bell of the instrument.  Also go to gigs and hear people live!  It’s the best lesson you will ever get.  The amount of great, great trumpet players that I go to hear and see zero of my trumpet students there in the audience alarms me.

When I was a young player, I attended the Wavendon Jazz Summer Course. Steve Waterman was teaching there and he was invaluable because he showed me all of these transcriptions of people like Lee Morgan and Miles Davis he had done.  Before that I was seriously groping in the dark, but I went home and started transcribing, and my jazz playing started rapidly improving.  It kind of makes me chuckle now when I tell my students they have to transcribe and some of the reactions of horror that I get, because it is quite a daunting prospect at first.  I remember transcribing from vinyl and cassettes because I didn’t have a CD player.  If you wanted to slow it down you had to buy a special cassette player from the US that slowed the music to half speed but made it an octave lower in pitch.  Now there are numerous computer apps that you can download in seconds for a few pounds that can slow the music down whilst keeping the pitch.

Teaching is really important to me.  I think that we have a lot of amazing players here in the UK that aren’t really appreciated enough, and the standard is getting better and better year after year.  I love being part of a team in the colleges that I teach at (Leeds College of Music, Guildhall School of Music and Drama, Birmingham Conservatoire, and the Royal Academy of Music).  When you manage to get the student to play better during the lesson and you see them getting the idea, coupled with seeing their progress over time, it’s exciting and very rewarding to feel you’ve been a part of that process.”

What projects do you currently have in the pipeline?

“I have a band co-led with my brother Matt, featuring Dave O’Higgins on Saxophone, Rob Barron on piano and Dario de Leche playing the music of Cedar Walton.  My brother and I had the honour of recording with Mr Walton in 2007 along with bass legend Peter Washington and my long standing musical partner Osian Roberts.

I recorded a CD last November with Alex Garnett on Alto Saxophone, New York bassist Mike Karn and Matt again on drums.  We’re currently working to get that mixed, mastered and released with a view to touring late next year.

Also in the pipeline is another sextet album as a follow up to our two previous CDs, In the Empire State and When Night Falls.  This band features Osian Roberts on Tenor, NYC musicians Frank Basile on Baritone, Mike Karn on bass and Jeb Patton on drums.  I’m writing music for that when I can find the time!”

Details on projects, recordings and future gigs can be found at www.stevefishwickjazz.com

Instrument details can be found at www.schilkemusic.com


Sign up here for new blog articles emailed direct to your inbox:

[jetpack_subscription_form show_subscribers_total=”false” button_on_newline=”false” submit_button_text=”Sign up” custom_font_size=”16″ custom_border_radius=”0″ custom_border_weight=”1″ custom_padding=”15″ custom_spacing=”10″ submit_button_classes=”” email_field_classes=”” show_only_email_and_button=”true”]

Playing with Braces

The decision to have braces during childhood can be a difficult decision to make… even before you consider how it will affect your trumpet playing!  While teaching I have lost count of the number of times that I been approached by students or their parents to tell me that their orthodontist has told them to stop playing.

I have also encountered a number of stories and experiences shared online by people that have really struggled to the point of having to give up the trumpet.  Another huge issue that often gets overlooked is what happens when the braces come off!

The purpose of this article is to give some advice and hope to young players, that not only can they continue to play, but that they can possibly even use this as an opportunity to really develop their trumpeting.

I have included here the thoughts and invaluable experience of Alan Thomas.  Alan is the Principal Trumpet of the BBC Symphony Orchestra and had braces aged 15-18, right up until commencing studies at Music College.  Here is a little of Alan’s experience in his own words!:

“I was lucky to have a very conscientious teacher in Richard Baker.  He moved my embouchure to the middle and got me going on progressive exercises.  Despite my protestations, he never allowed me to give up.  He teaches for East Sussex and now runs the very successful Hangleton Youth Brass Band (50+ young brass players), the band where I started.  I achieved grade 8 distinction as well as double A level in music, and had a range safely up to a top C by the end. 

At my Birmingham Conservatoire audition, Andy Stone-Fewings remembers my audition with braces.  They asked me to demonstrate my range and apparently I got up to only an E or F?!  Out of all the UK colleges, I only got into Trinity College of Music and Birmingham.  What was interesting was that I was in-and-out very quickly at the other colleges, but Norman Burgess at Trinity and Andy and Jon Holland at Birmingham took time to analyse my playing. It was interesting that these colleges were looking for potential more than a finished article and showed faith in me. I try to do the same when I’m on audition panels now.

My original intention was to do these auditions as a dry-run for the following year without braces, but after a positive experience at audition, I decided to give Birmingham a go.  I started there 6 months after braces were out. I then had plenty of time to work on my playing for the next 4 years.”

The first and most important adjustment that you need to make is one of thought process and attitude.  The big positive with adjusting to playing the trumpet with braces is that the focus HAS to be on the air.  The discomfort of the braces digging in and also the added strain on isolated parts of the inner lip will most likely have an effect.

Alan: “You must also not forget about the positives that you are getting out of this: you have an opportunity to learn to play with minimum pressure, reset a less-than-ideal embouchure… and get a set of nice teeth!”

The second big change needs to be one of routine.  Be slow and patient.  Listen.  Slowly find a comfortable range (even if it is just one note to start) and gradually build on it.  You will also find that practicing in short bursts is far more beneficial.

Alan: “Concentrate on the basics and do not push the range too early.  You should use this opportunity to hone other techniques such as double/triple tonguing, low flexibility with low resistance, and pedal tones can be very useful.  Nice tunes are essential as just playing exercises can be so demoralizing.”

Thirdly, it may be worth considering gadgets!  There are a number of interesting products on the market that may help to make playing more comfortable.  Some players have found that using wax straps or brace guards have eased the problem of the braces digging in.  Others have found that they actually make playing harder as the lips get pushed that bit further forward.  It is certainly worth trying though.

Another thing to consider is the mouthpiece.  Sometimes a slightly wider rim can help.  A couple of interesting options that I have found are from Greg Black and Wedge.

Alan: “I never used any of these.  I found that the strips and guards interrupted air flow and increased the size of the braces on my teeth.” 

Finally, you need to plan for the braces being removed.  This can feel as alien as when the braces first go on.

Alan: “This needs to be judged carefully as you can easily go back to using excess pressure.  Again, take a bit of time off usual playing to get used to things.  I think that I went onto the back row at band again for a while.  Build your range steadily.  Concentrate on getting the lips to vibrate well in the mouthpiece.  I still have a cut off mouthpiece that I use to visualize this.” 

Through all of this process, it is obviously incredibly important to consult closely with your orthodontist who can guide you through the different options.  I have come across an interesting article online from the British Orthodontic Society giving a good overview, which you may find useful too.

Alan: “I definitely feel that the braces helped my long-term development.  It is easier to keep my teeth clean and I now have a fabulous ‘Wallace & Gromit’ smile!  I have a good central embouchure, which I have been told looks effortless.  It was very difficult at the time, but I had a lot of support from family, friends, bandmaster and teachers.”


Sign up here for new blog articles emailed direct to your inbox:

[jetpack_subscription_form show_subscribers_total=”false” button_on_newline=”false” submit_button_text=”Sign up” custom_font_size=”16″ custom_border_radius=”0″ custom_border_weight=”1″ custom_padding=”15″ custom_spacing=”10″ submit_button_classes=”” email_field_classes=”” show_only_email_and_button=”true”]